Well the key to things like this is, I think, to pick things that are appropriate to the character. For instance, 'popping their cherry' is redundant for Andras and Teja because we know how it was done in each case [and in each case it was pretty 0_o]!

I don't, and won't, know Donovan so he's out, and of the other three Teja is favourite, followed by Ricky. Since it's important also to pick things that the writer will enjoy writing about their characters I choose 'well-shagged' for Teja and 'popping their cherry' for Ricky.

I'll not do the meme - these things are embarrassing when nobody replies - but I'll do my 250 words instead.