Cultural appropriation
Dec. 16th, 2010 10:55 amCultural appropriation is what they yell in the (sometimes painfully) Politically Correct circles on tumblr when somebody adapts style element that are associated with some sort of underprivileged culture.
For example:
Cultural cross-pollination, even thought it may have seemed ridiculous at the time and/or in hindsight, is what friggin' drove the development of human culture throughout history. A kendoka from East Germany with bright red dreadlocks in a bright red hakama? Probably ridiculous and culturally appropriating in too many ways than can be told before I need to catch my train. But really, that's where the world is going.
Culture doesn't belong to anybody. It kind of sloshes around in the global meme pool. When privileged strangers start experimenting with whatever other people have done for ages, it may look a bit silly; but after a few centuries, chinoiserie cabinets and mithraeums will be regarded as the classical expressions of rococo and Roman culture, respectively...
For example:
- White people should not wear dreads -- this hairstyle belongs to the black culture, so it's appropriation (Warning: NSFW image behind link!)
- Non-Asian-descended Americans and Europeans converting to Buddhism is such a silly fad and insults the people of Tibet, Myanmar etc., where Buddhism is such an important part of their struggle.
- White people should not rap -- ditto
- White or black people should not incorporate the Dia de los Muertos elements in their Halloween festivities. That's Mexican. Cultural appropriation! No sugar skulls for you!
- Westerners should not get large tattoos of swirly ornaments. Please stick to your hearts and mermaids. Tribal tattoos belong to South Sea people; adopting them is cheap cultural appropriation. Oh, and Scythians. But Scythians are different. They are dead.
- Westerners should not enjoy Korean soap operas with people wearing outrageous clothes. They are for Koreans only. Cultural appropriation!
- White people should not enjoy Bollywood movies, or cook Indian meals, or drink chai or lassi, while they do so. Combining bright pink and bright orange is stealing Indian culture, too. Cultural appropriation!
- Straight men are required to dress drably and be rude louts. If they take good care of their clothes, looks and living space, thinking about the effect it will have, and are attentive and caring to others instead of kicking back and watching football while drinking beer, they're culturally appropriating the behaviour of their girlfriends' gay BFFs in order to gain points - booooh!
- Westerners should not get into manga, anime, or cosplay. They shouldn't even practice zen, ikebana, or kendo. That's Japanese, and doing it is bad, bad cultural appropriation!
- Protestant people should be completely barred from owning Orthodox icons, let alone display them on their walls.
- German or English people should not listen to Irish Folk. Celtic knot-work, and tartans, are off-limits, too. Especially tartans. Absolutely nobody who is not Celtic should wear anything remotely like plaid! Keep your greedy Germanic paws off our Celtic heritage. Booo! Cultural appropriation! P.S.: And don't you dare hold an impromptu wake on the night before your grandfather's funeral, with four people reminiscing and working their way down the bottle of the strong stuff into the wee small hours. Don't even call it wee small hours to start with! Shush!
- Pizza and spaghetti are Italian. It's really inappropriate to culturally appropriate a small Mediterranean country's cuisine into world-wide favourite staples, especially for kids. Boooh!
- Westerners should not make porcelain and display it in special China cabinets. They shouldn't even import it from China. Porcelain is for the Chinese people only. Oh, and please give us back our tea!
- Speaking of which, coffee is Arabic. And chocolate is Mexican. If you drink any of these, it's cultural appropriation.
- Christian westerners, stick to your apples and pears! Peaches and dates are oriental, and it's really the height of cultural appropriation to first send a large number of crusades into the east and then steal our fruit as well. Oh, and dainty moorish columns look ridiculous on your northerly castles. Don't do it!
- Draco standards! A Scythian/Sarmatian invention! Every last damn barbaric army throughout this entire Migration age hullaballoo adopting them is really a blatant case of cultural appropriation.
- Roman women shouldn't bleach their hair to try and turn blonde like their lovely Germanic and Celtic slaves, that's ridiculous and unbecoming!
- No more cult of Mithras! It's a ridiculous imported eastern religion unbecoming a Roman or Greek. Same holds true for the worship of Isis. Oh, and that weird cult, what do they call it again? Christianity? That's a Jewish sect, for Jupiter's sake!
- Erm, no, actually, we don't want any former pagans to become Christians in the first place. This man Saulus who now calls himself Paul is going down totally the wrong path and encouraging people to culturally appropriate. That's all wrong...
- Keeping cats is an Egyptian custom. You Romans, Greeks, Northmen, Persians, Scythians, what have you, really really should keep your hands off our beloved and revered pets. You don't even worship them properly but merely like them. Blasphemy! Cultural appropriation!
- First those Romans conquer Greece, and then they copy all our statues and equate their rustic gods with our own. And that hack Virgil writes this ridiculous pseudo-Odyssey about Aeneas from Troy to justify that they, too, are descended from civilised and historic people mentioned in Homer. If you get down to it, it's just blatant fanfic. Actually, they steal everything from our culture that isn't on the trees at the count of three. It's deeply embarrassing, and highly ridiculous. Really. Romans culturally appropriate fucking anything!
- We are Tibet! We have Bön! Do we really need to culturally appropriate Buddhism from India?
- We are China! We have Confucianism! Do we really need to culturally appropriate Buddhism from Tibet?
- We are Japan! We have Shintô! Do we really need to culturally appropriate Buddhism from China?
- We don't want those big rude hunter-gatherers with their big rude dogs to adopt our way of keeping cattle and tilling the ground to plant and harvest grain, fruit, and herbs. They're all over the continent, and we are sitting here on the shore of Lake Balaton, a tiny minority from the south-east. Neolithic revolution isn't for mainstream mesolithic culture to appropriate!
- Trading ways of working flint and bone, and painting the walls of caves, up and down the Danube and the Rhone really means that one culture appropriates the specialities of another, and that's really not done! We must all keep our customs separate so everybody can see which is which.
Cultural cross-pollination, even thought it may have seemed ridiculous at the time and/or in hindsight, is what friggin' drove the development of human culture throughout history. A kendoka from East Germany with bright red dreadlocks in a bright red hakama? Probably ridiculous and culturally appropriating in too many ways than can be told before I need to catch my train. But really, that's where the world is going.
Culture doesn't belong to anybody. It kind of sloshes around in the global meme pool. When privileged strangers start experimenting with whatever other people have done for ages, it may look a bit silly; but after a few centuries, chinoiserie cabinets and mithraeums will be regarded as the classical expressions of rococo and Roman culture, respectively...